Journal of Literary Criticism and Rhetoric

Journal of Literary Criticism and Rhetoric

Analysis of Neurotic Mechanism of Moving Toward People in Masnavi Stories Based on Karen Horney’s Neuroticism Theory

Document Type : scientific-research

Authors
Shahram Mahmoodi 1
Ebrahim Danesh 2
Faramarz Jalalat 3
1 Ph.D. Candidate Department of Language and literature, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor of Persian Language and Literature, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran.
3 Assistant Professor Department of Language and literature, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran.
10.22059/jlcr.2021.313817.1582
Abstract
Human beings confront so many hardships in their life, and these hardships affect their life and personality. Some basic hardships of childhood, such as parents’ improper behavior, lead to sufferings that have a fundamental role in a person’s life and actions in the maturity period. These important and influential sufferings result in abnormal behaviors in one’s different periods of life. Karen Horney, a German psychologist, has an important theory about human psychological sufferings known as “Neuroticism.” She discusses the causes of neuroticism and considers some mechanisms as defensive behaviors or structures that the neurotic person uses to relieve their pain and reach relaxation. One of these mechanisms is “moving toward people”. Horney believes that all of the mechanisms, especially the mechanism of moving toward people that neurotic person refuges in, are not treatments. Not only they do not provide security and comfort for neurotics, but they also exacerbate their neuroticism. Rumi as a great mystic, poet, and thinker that has used the Quran, Islamic and Iranian knowledge in addition to a great deal of the common knowledges of his time, and compiled so many universal works such as Masnavi and Gazaliyyate Shams, according to his mission i.e. saving people and bringing them to the prosperity, was not indifferent to the inner and psychological sufferings of human beings. He has had deep thoughts and reflections on human psychological issues and has presented many valuable ideas in this regard. Rumi has competently pointed out the causes of the tendency to the mechanism of moving toward people and its complications and consequences in his stories and allegories. This paper will investigate the different manifestations of the mechanism in the anecdotes and allegories of Rumi, clarifying the position of this mechanism in the actions of neurotic characters of his stories and allegories
Keywords
Neuroticism
Karen Horney
Moving Toward Teople
Rumi
Masnavie Manavi

Adim, Abdollah & Golizadeh, Parvin, 2015, An Analisis of Shams’s Carrachter and His Relationship with Molavi from Psychology Point of View based on Karen Horney’s carrachter Theory, Journal of Researches on Mistical Literature, 51-70. [In Persian].

Aghayoosefi, Alireza & Others, 2018, General Psychology, 17th edition, Tehran: Payame Noor University. [In Persian].
Barzgar, Ebrahim, 2010, Horney Theory & Nasereddin Shah’s Political Psychology from his childhood up to Noori’s Deposal, Journal of Research Letter of Political Sciences. 35-73. [In Persian].
Behnamfar, Mohammad & Talayi, Zeinab, 2014, Psychological Criticism of Carrachter in Salmargi Novel Based on Karen Horney’s Theory, Journal of Literary text Research. 175-193. [In Persian].
Ghazzali, Mohammad, 2002, Ehyae Oloom-el-Din, Translated by Moayyed-ol-Din Kharazmi, 4th edition, Tehran, Elmi & Farhangi. [In Persian].
Hitchcock, Susan Tyler, 2005, Karen Horney : pioneer of feminine psychology, Chelsea House Publishers, PhiladelphiaZamani, Karim, 2008, A Comprehensive Commentary of Masnavi Manavi, 19th edition, Tehran: Ettelaat. [In Persian].
Holy Quran, 2008, Translated by Mahdi Elahi Qomshei, Tehran: Kashef. [In Arabic & Persian].
Horney, Karen, 1999, The Therapeutic Process: Essays and Lectures, Yale University Press, New Haven, London.
Javanmard, Gholamhosein, 2018, A Brief History & Schools of Psychology, 11th edition, Tehran: Payame Noor University. [In Persian].
Karen, Horney, 1990, The Neurotic Personality of Our Time, Trnslated by Ebrahim Khajenoori, 5th edition, Tehran: Shargh. [In Persian].
Karen, Horney,, 2010, Our Inner Conflict, Translated by Maryam Vatar, First edition, Tehran: Elm. [In Persian].
Karen, Horney,, 2018 A, Feminine Psychology, Translated by Soheil Sommi, 8th edition, Tehran: Ghoghnoos. [In Persian].
Karen, Horney,, 2018 B, Our Inner Conflict, Translated by Mohammad Jafar Mosaffa, 23th edition, Tehran: Bahjat. [In Persian].
Karen, Horney,, 2019, Self-Analysis, Translated by Mohammad Jafar Mosaffa, 14th edition, Tehran: Bahjat. [In Persian].
Molavi, Jalal-ol-Din Mohammad, 2007, Fihe Ma Fih, Edited by Badi-ol-Zaman Froozanfar, Second edition, Tehran: Negah. [In Persian].
Molavi, Jalal-ol-Din Mohammad, 2011, Masnavi Manavi, Edited by Reynold A. Nicholson, 5th edition, Tehran: Hermes. [In Persian].
Nordby, Vernon, J. & Hall, Calvin S, 1990, A Guide to Great Psychologists Theory, Translated by Ahmad Behpajooh & R. P. Dolati. First edition, Tehran: Roshd. [In Persian].
Shakeri, Jalil & Bakhshi, Behnaz, 2015, Psychological Analysis of Characters of Three Storeis from Gholamhosein Sâedi (Beggar, Distitutes, and Garbage can) According to Karen Horney’s theory, Journal of Literary text Research. 55-88. [In Persian].
Shariatmadari, Ali, 1990,  An Introduction to Psychology, 4th edition, Isfahan: Jungle. [In Persian].
Sholtz, Sideney Ellen, 2003, A History of Modern Psychology, Translated by Ali Akbar Seif & Others, Second edition, Tehran: Doran. [In Persian].
Solomon, Irving, 2006, Karen, Horney and character disorder: a guide for the modern practitioner, Springer Publishing Company, Inc, New York.

  • Receive Date 16 November 2020
  • Revise Date 20 February 2021
  • Accept Date 09 May 2021